THE SKELETAL REMAINS of Penang Woman, a 5,000-year-old skull discovered at Guar Kepah in 2017, offer a unique opportunity to explore the intersection of bioarchaeology and forensic science.

Determining the biological sex of early human remains is a critical step in reconstructing individual identities; sexual dimorphism in the skeleton can provide insights into the biology and social structures of ancient populations. Penang Woman’s skull has become a focal point for advanced techniques like forensic facial approximation, which not only visualises her features, but also bridges the gap between scientific analysis and human connection.

This study highlights how modern methods—such as sex estimation through cranial morphology and three-dimensional (3D) facial reconstruction—shed light on the lives of ancient individuals, while challenging existing narratives about migration and ancestry in Southeast Asia.

Sexual Dimorphism in the Human Skeleton

The fundamental concept underpinning skeletal sex determination is sexual dimorphism, which describes physical differences in the size and shape of males and females of the same species. In humans, these differences are largely driven by unique developmental pathways, varying hormonal responses to environmental stimuli and, historically, adaptations caused by the gendered division of labour. Generally, biological males tend to exhibit larger, more robust skeletal structures, often reflecting greater muscle mass and overall body size. Conversely, females typically present smaller and smoother skeletal features. These differences become most pronounced after puberty, making sex determination in child skeletons especially challenging.

When forensic anthropologists and bioarchaeologists analyse skeletal remains, the pelvis is often considered the most reliable bone for sex estimation, boasting an accuracy rate of up to 95% when well-preserved—the distinct adaptations of the female pelvis for childbirth result in a wider pelvic inlet and a larger subpubic angle compared to males. However, archaeological contexts frequently present incomplete or fragmented remains where the pelvis may be absent or too damaged for reliable analysis. In such scenarios, the skull becomes the next most reliable structure for sex determination, as is the case with Penang Woman.

The scientific process of sex determination from skeletal remains, while aiming for a binary biological classification, reveals the inherent biological fluidity and variability within human populations. Skeletal traits are not always definitively male or female; instead, influenced by factors such as ancestry, environmental conditions and age, they often lie along a continuum, ranging from “very female” to “very male”. For instance, it can be nearly impossible to differentiate sex in child skeletons, and some populations naturally possess more delicate or robust skeletal structures than others, meaning a feature that appears female in one population might be male in another.

Archaeologists who impose a strict gender binary solely based on skeletal traits risk overlooking historical reality due to their application of an anachronistic framework on past societies. The limited perspective involved can lead to misinterpretations of social roles, for example, incorrectly assuming that ancient women could not have used axes or that men could not have worn rings, as the case can be if only grave goods are considered. The need to acknowledge this continuum underscores the importance of interdisciplinary approaches that combine rigorous osteological analysis with broader archaeological and cultural interpretations.

Reading the Cranium: Morphological Clues and Interpretations

One foundational approach to determining biological sex from skeletal remains is the anthroposcopic assessment, often described as the “qualitative art” of visual inspection. This involves a trained eye examining specific skeletal features, typically evaluating them on a subjective scale (e.g., from 1 for “very female”, to 5 for “very male”).

While crucial for preliminary assessment, this method relies heavily on the experience and judgment of the examiner, which can be subjective and unreliable—particularly if the remains are fragmented or incomplete.

Forensic anthropologists meticulously examine several key sexually dimorphic features of the skull for sex identification, such as the forehead and brow. When viewed in profile, male foreheads tend to be less rounded and slope backward at a gentler angle, often featuring a prominent ridge above the eye sockets, known as the supraorbital ridge. In contrast, female skulls typically exhibit a more rounded, vertical forehead, and their supraorbital ridge is generally smoother.

Another telling indicator relates to the jaw region. Males typically present a square jawline, with the angle between the outer edge of the jaw and the ear appearing more vertical. They also often have a more pronounced chin, known as the mental eminence. Female jaws, conversely, are usually more pointed, and the angle of the jaw slopes gently towards the ear.

Despite their utility, these morphological methods come with inherent limitations. As noted, their subjective nature can lead to inconsistent results between examiners. Furthermore, factors such as age can significantly influence skeletal morphology; for instance, the skulls of elderly women may sometimes develop characteristics that resemble those typically found in males. Crucially, sexual dimorphism varies markedly between different populations, underscoring the necessity of population-specific reference data.

To overcome the inherent subjectivity of purely morphological assessments, bioarchaeologists employ craniometrics, the scientific measurement of the skull. This quantitative approach provides objective, quantifiable data, significantly reducing examiner bias and offering scientifically verifiable results. It transforms visual observations into numerical data that can be rigorously analysed.

Computed Tomography (CT) and 3D Modelling: Visualising with Unprecedented Detail

The integration of medical imaging technologies, particularly Computed Tomography (CT) scans, has revolutionised the study of skeletal remains in bioarchaeology; it has allowed for the creation of high-resolution 3D digital models of skulls and other bones without the need for potentially damaging physical manipulation. This non-invasive approach helps in the conservation of irreplaceable archaeological heritage.

In the context of sex determination, CT images provide exceptionally detailed views of both the external and internal cranial morphology, which facilitate precise landmark placement for traditional metric and advanced geometric morphometric analyses.

The 3D models derived from CT scans are also instrumental in forensic facial approximation, as demonstrated by the Penang Woman project. These digital models enable the virtual reconstruction of missing or damaged skeletal elements, and critically, they allow for the accurate application of population-specific soft tissue thickness markers, bringing ancient faces to life with remarkable anatomical accuracy.

Penang Woman: A Forensic Archaeology Case Study

The forensic facial approximation of Penang Woman was a meticulous, multi-step process that exemplified the success of cutting-edge scientific methodologies applied to ancient remains. After undergoing a CT scan at Hospital USM, the resulting Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) data of the skull were used to create a detailed 3D model of the skull, using Blender software.

The forensic facial approximation of Penang Woman yielded several fascinating findings. Her intracranial volume was measured at 1,330mL, a figure remarkably comparable to the average intracranial volume of modern humans (averaging 1,328mL), suggesting that Penang Woman’s brain capacity was fully within the modern range.

Perhaps the most compelling finding was the revelation of a blend of ancestral features in her facial reconstruction—the skull displayed characteristics consistent with both Mongoloid and Australomelanesoid ancestries.

The Mongoloid features observed included a rounded orbital margin (eye sockets), a medium-width nasal aperture, moderate prognathism (protruding jaw), an absent brow ridge, a straight nasal profile, wide facial breadth, and a flatter, broader, squarer face with prominent cheekbones.

On the other hand, the Australomelanesoid features include a squarer orbital margin, a large and elongated mastoid process (the bony bump behind the ear), and a clear temporal line in the parietal region of the skull. This blend of features strongly supports earlier hypotheses proposed by researchers such as Teuku Jacob, who suggested that the ancient Guar Kepah population was a “mixture of Mongoloid and Australomelanesian races”. The presence of these irregular features indicate non-homogenous racial characteristics, likely due to interbreeding that occurred over a long period of time.

The Penang Woman’s missing upper jaw and lower jaw were digitally reconstructed by distorting a 3D mesh from a virtual donor, using a sophisticated technique that ensures anatomical coherence even with missing body parts. A crucial aspect of achieving an accurate facial approximation is the application of soft tissue thickness markers. For Penang Woman, these markers were meticulously applied based on CT scan data derived from 34 modern Malays. Additional measurements for the height of the ears and eye openness were also incorporated from Malay population data. This emphasis on population-specificity is paramount, as soft tissue thicknesses vary significantly across different ancestral groups, directly impacting the accuracy of the final facial reconstruction.

To ensure the reconstructed soft tissue conforms accurately to the underlying bone structure, the CT scans of two Malay individuals were imported. An anatomical deformation technique was then employed to conform the donor’s skull mesh and soft tissue to Penang Woman, maintaining the fine anatomical features, while adjusting for the unique contours of Penang Woman’s skull.

Throughout the process, a comprehensive set of facial measurements guided the reconstruction. These included lateral nasal projection (distances and angles for the nose), inter-orbital distances for eyeball positioning, and mouth measurements and ear height. Precise measurements of these, combined with the 3D modelling, allowed for a highly realistic and scientifically informed reconstruction. The flowchart shows the steps taken to create the Penang woman.

A Face from 5,000 Years Ago, A Window to Our Past

The meticulous reconstruction of Penang Woman’s face and the detailed analysis of her skull have prompted a significant reassessment of the biological and ancestral affinities associated with the broader Guar Kepah skeletal collection. Her face tells a story of ancient interbreeding and cultural exchange, providing tangible evidence for theories like the “two-layer hypothesis”, which posits that Eastern Asia was initially occupied by Australo-Papuans before being replaced by or admixing with Neolithic agriculturalists possessing East Asian cranial morphology.

The cranial analysis of Penang Woman is notably compatible with the “transitional Neolithic” period. Beyond its scientific contributions, the process and techniques employed in the study of Penang Woman indirectly promote digital documentation in the conservation of human remains.

The journey to reconstruct the face of Penang Woman, a 5,000-year-old inhabitant of the Guar Kepah shell midden, stands as a remarkable testament to the meticulous work of bioarchaeologists. Her skull, once a mere bone fragment, has yielded a wealth of information not only about her biological sex, but also about her complex ancestral origins and the broader human story of ancient Penang. This endeavour underscores the enduring power of forensic archaeology and anthropology. These disciplines are not simply about identifying the deceased; they are about reconstructing entire lifeways, understanding social structures and discerning the environmental adaptations of ancient populations.

Penang Woman’s story is a compelling example of how science can connect us intimately with our ancestors and foster a deeper appreciation of the intricate human journey that unfolded over vast stretches of time. Looking forward, Penang Woman is just one face from the past, but her story opens countless doors to understanding our shared heritage and the remarkable adaptability of human populations.

REFERENCES

1. željana Bašić, I. Anterić, K. Vilović, A. Petaros, A. Bosnar, T. Madžar, O. Polašek, Š. Andelinović, Sex determination in skeletal remains from the medieval Eastern Adriatic coast – discriminant function analysis of humeri, Croat Med J 54 (2013) 272. https://doi.org/10.3325/ CMJ.2013.54.272

2. J.Y. Abdullah, C. Moraes, M. Saidin, Z.A. Rajion, H. Hadi, S. Shahidan, J.M. Abdullah, Forensic Facial Approximation of 5000-Year-Old Female Skull from Shell Midden in Guar Kepah, Malaysia, Applied Sciences 2022, Vol. 12, Page 7871 12 (2022) 7871. https://doi.org/10.3390/ APP12157871.

3. 5,000-year-old ‘Penang Woman’ on display at archeological site in Guar Kepah | Malay Mail, (2019). https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2019/05/10/5000- year-old-penang-woman-ondisplay-at-archeological-site-inguar-kepah/1751575 (accessed June 22, 2025).

4. Becky Bahr, Fiveable. “sex determination techniques – Intro to Archaeology.,” Fiveable (2024). https://library.fiveable. me/key-terms/introduction-archaeology/sex-determination-techniques (accessed June 24, 2025).

5. X. Wang, G. Liu, Q. Wu, Y. Zheng, F. Song, Y. Li, Sex estimation techniques based on skulls in forensic anthropology: A scoping review, PLoS One 19 (2024) e0311762. https:// doi.org/10.1371/JOURNAL. PONE.0311762.

6. željana Bašić, I. Anterić, K. Vilović, A. Petaros, A. Bosnar, T. Madžar, O. Polašek, Š. Andelinović, Sex determination in skeletal remains from the medieval Eastern Adriatic coast – discriminant function analysis of humeri, Croat Med J 54 (2013) 272. https://doi.org/10.3325/CMJ.2013.54.272.

7. P. Mahakkanukrauh, A. Sinthubua, S. Prasitwattanaseree, S. Ruengdit, P. Singsuwan, S. Praneatpolgrang, P. Duangto, Craniometric study for sex determination in a Thai population, Anat Cell Biol 48 (2015) 275. https://doi.org/10.5115/ACB.2015.48.4.275.

8. T.J.-Ph.D. Dissertation, U. of Utrecht, undefined 1967, Some problems pertaining to the racial history of the Indonesian region, 1967. https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1571980074908862464 (accessed June 22, 2025).

9. Two layer hypothesis - Wikipedia, (2025). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_layer_ hypothesis (accessed June 22, 2025).